Essay 3: Research Paper

Write a 1,700–2,000 word (7–8 page) essay on Macbeth that presents new and surprising information to your reader. You must support the analysis in your essay with both your own careful close reading of the text and with secondary sources. Your essay should employ a Surprising Reversal structure.

Since Macbeth as a whole is too mammoth a topic to cover in a brief essay, you will need to limit the scope of you paper. The best way to focus your essay is to look a single scene—or part of a scene—from Macbeth. That should help keep your essay within manageable limits.

Sources
For this essay, you will have one primary source (the text of Macbeth) and at least four secondary sources all documented in proper MLA format. Your secondary sources might include critical essay or books on Macbeth, Shakespeare’s own sources (like Holinshed’s Chronicles), cultural and historical backgrounds, stage history—including filmed versions of the play, or anything else that might help support your analysis.

The essay must have a Works Cited page with full bibliographic information on your sources and employ in-text citations and parenthetical references. Use proper MLA style for formatting your document.

See MLA Style: “Document Format,” “Citation Format,” “How to Quote Shakespeare,” and “Documenting Sources.”

Surprising Reversal
A Surprising Reversal essay first presents a common answer to a question, then presents the writer’s new, surprising view on that question.

Before you start drafting your essay, make sure you can answer each of the following questions:

  1. What question does your essay address?
  2. What is the common, expected, or popular answer to this question that your audience holds?
  3. What examples and details support your audience’s view?
  4. What is your own surprising view?
  5. What examples and details support this view? Why do you hold this view? Why should a reader believe you?

Thesis
Rather than appearing at the end of the introduction, the thesis in a Surprising Reversal essay appears after the writer has summarized the common view. A Surprising Reversal thesis will generally take this form: “Although many people believe X (common view), I am going to show you Y (new, surprising view).”

Here are some examples of Surprising-Reversal thesis statements:

  • Although most people believe Native Americans lived in harmony with nature, many Native American tribes altered their environment aggressively, burning down forests to make farming easier and hunting some animals to the edge of extinction.
  • To most audiences, The Bride of Frankenstein is a monster movie about science run amok, yet many in the gay community interpret the film as an allegory about homosexual identity.

Structure
Your introduction should arouse the reader’s curiosity by posing an interesting question. The next section should first summarize a common or expected answer to the question, then present your thesis—your surprising answer to the question. Then, in the rest of your paper, provide new, surprising information that reverses or modifies the common view. (Imagine readers who hold a mistaken or overly narrow view of your topic; your purpose is to give them a new, surprising view.) In your conclusion, summarize your main points and clearly present the significance of your new perspective. Make sure every paragraph has a clear topic sentence.

Structure for a Surprising Reversal Essay

Introduction
  • Engage the reader’s interest in your question.
  • Provides background and context if necessary.
Common View
  • Present the common or popular answer to your question.
  • Provides delayed thesis—your surprising answer to the question.
Surprising View
  • Develop and support the thesis with information from your own textual analysis and from your research.
Conclusion
  • Make final comments about the significance of your new perspective on the question.

Style
Make your prose as clear and concise as possible. Don’t waste your time (or mine!) trying to sound impressive. Write, instead, in a conversational voice: the clear, plainspoken, engaging voice of a person talking about a subject they find interesting. Make every word count.

Drafts
I encourage you to write a rotten first draft of your essay as soon as possible and use it to help you build a better paper. You do not have to submit a rough draft to me, but if you want me to read and respond to your work in progress, I will gladly do so. You can send your work in progress to me as an email attachment or give me a hard copy of it in class. You may submit your work in progress for my feedback anytime before the Draft Deadline: Friday, November 18.

Proofreading
Before you submit your essay for a grade, proofread it carefully and thoroughly, correcting any errors in spelling, punctuation, grammar, and MLA formatting. Slapdash spelling, sloppy punctuation, semiliterate grammar, or slipshod MLA formatting seriously undermines your credibility as a writer.

Therefore, essays with excessive errors in spelling, punctuation, grammar, or MLA formatting will receive no higher than a D.

Evaluation
In evaluating your essay, I will focus on the originality and insightfulness of your thesis, the precision of your analysis, and the clarity of your prose. (See the “Grading Criteria for Major Essays” on the Syllabus.)
Submit your essay through the TurnItIn link on the class Blackboard page labeled “Essay 3: Research Paper.”

Due Dates:

  • DRAFT DEADLINE: November 18

  • FINAL DRAFT DUE: December 2*

    * I hereby grant to anyone who wants it a one week extension on the paper. Note, however, that late papers get no written comments from me and that I won’t accept any papers submitted later than one week past the due date: December 9.

Page Last Updated: 2 November 2016